2009 Lucien Le Moine, Chambolle-Musigny Premier Cru, Les Charmes 1x750ml

Vinous 91

Medium red. Nose initially dominated by smoky oak and spices, with red fruits emerging after some aeration. Suave, lush and scented; fine-grained and sweet. This has turned out to be broader and fatter than a barrel sample suggested last year, but can’t match the best 2009s at this address for energy. Finishes with a chocolatey perfume. [Stephen Tanzer, 03/01/2012]

Robert Parker 91

The 2009 Chambolle-Musigny Les Charmes showcases the more muscular, intense side of Chambolle in its powerful, intense fruit. Firm tannins frame the insistent finish. Anticipated maturity: 2019-2029. These wines from proprietor Mounir Saouma are impressive. Saouma sources small lots of wine from the best sites in Burgundy and does all of the post-alcoholic fermentation elevage in his cellar in Beaune. Saouma’s approach calls for long, slow malos, extended contact on the gross lees and no fining or filtration prior to bottling. Saouma bottles an eye-popping 60 different wines, some sourced from more than one grower. Count me as a fervent believer in terroir. As much as I subscribe to the belief that specific plots of land can confer unique qualities to wines, the reality is that a variety of other factors are just as important, including the talent of the winemaker and the ambient qualities of the cellars in which wines are raised. What amazes me most about these wines " aside from the obviously very high quality " is that there is without question a distinctive house style that emerges across the range, despite the fact that they come from different sources and are acquired as wine rather than fruit. Saouma likes to describe his cellar as a library of Burgundy’s finest terroirs. That’s as good a description as any for these uniformly outstanding, compelling wines. Importer: Vintus LLC, Pleasantville, NY; tel. (914) 769-3000, Atherton Imports, Menlo Park, CA; tel. (650) 328-6639 [Antonio Galloni, 02/05/2011]

Anticipated maturity: 2019-2029